Dining With Denise Neil

A Wichita restaurant that left the west side in 2020 is about to return — with some tweaks

Mike Brotemarkle shared this photo of the renovation underway at the former Baskin-Robbins space on West 21st Street. He’s turning it into a version of his restaurant, Crafted, but it will be called Sharky’s Island Bites.
Mike Brotemarkle shared this photo of the renovation underway at the former Baskin-Robbins space on West 21st Street. He’s turning it into a version of his restaurant, Crafted, but it will be called Sharky’s Island Bites.

Four years after a Wichita restaurant left the west side, it’s about to return.

And in a strange twist, it will open in a space directly next door to the one it vacated in 2020.

Crafted owner Mike Brotemarkle, who in August 2019 opened his coffee and poke restaurant at 9730 E. 21st St., says that he and his wife, Vicky Dao, have taken over the former Baskin-Robbins space at 8918 W. 21st St. It’s on the far west end of the strip center just in front of the Regal Warren West movie theatre.

The logo for Sharky’s Island Bites
The logo for Sharky’s Island Bites Courtesy

That’s where they plan to open a second restaurant that will be similar to Crafted but will have a different name — and a slightly different approach. The new restaurant will be called Sharky’s Island Bites, Brotemarkle said, and it will specialize in poke and hot Hawaiian plate lunches. It will also carry a limited coffee menu and serve Dole Whip, something Crafted is known for, as well as specialty boba drinks.

It’s just an odd coincidence, Brotemarkle said, that the space is right next door to where his previous west-side restaurant, Poke Mix, once operated. That restaurant, which was focused solely on build-your-own poke dishes, opened in 2017, but Brotemarkle and his then partners decided to close it just as the pandemic was starting in 2020. They’d just opened Crafted seven months earlier.

Sharky’s Island Bites will focus on build-your-own poke and Hawaiian plate lunches.
Sharky’s Island Bites will focus on build-your-own poke and Hawaiian plate lunches. Courtesy photo

“It had been posted for lease for a while, and we just kind of inquired about it,” Brotemarkle said of the west-side space. “We didn’t really think anything of it. It was just a good deal, and we couldn’t pass it up.”

Though it’s in the same strip center, the space for Sharky’s is better than the Pokemix spot next door because it has a drive-through, Brotemarkle said. Crafted has one, too, and it’s become an important piece of the concept.

Why are Crafted’s owners giving their west-side restaurant a different name?

Crafted opened at 21st and Webb in 2019.
Crafted opened at 21st and Webb in 2019. Courtesy photo

Brotemarkle said that they have plans to franchise their poke concept, and they want potential franchisees to have two options: a smaller restaurant (Sharky’s) focused on poke and plate lunches, and a larger version (Crafted) that also has a full coffee menu.

“It allows us to give the ability to choose what kind of setting or poke restaurant they would like,” he said.

Sharky’s should open by mid- to late May, Brotemarkle said. It will have seating inside for 36 and will offer fun merchandise targeted at both adults and kids.

“It will be pretty kid friendly, and the menu will be really open for the entire family,” he said.

Brotemarkle also has a food truck that it has been using for catering and special events since last year. It will soon be branded as Sharky’s Island Bites, and he plans to start taking it out more often. Its focus is Hawaiian plate lunches.

Stay tuned for more information as Sharky’s Island Bites gets closer to opening.

Crafted’s year-old food truck is about to get a wrap that will identify it with Sharky’s Island Bites. When finished, it should look like this photo.
Crafted’s year-old food truck is about to get a wrap that will identify it with Sharky’s Island Bites. When finished, it should look like this photo. Courtesy
Denise Neil
The Wichita Eagle
Denise Neil has covered restaurants and entertainment since 1997. Her Dining with Denise Facebook page is the go-to place for diners to get information about local restaurants. She’s a regular judge at local food competitions and speaks to groups all over Wichita about dining.
Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER