Kathleen Parker: Country not as divided as one might imagine

10/17/2013 5:08 PM

10/17/2013 5:08 PM

This just in from a new Esquire/NBC News study: There are more Americans in the vast middle than on either the left or right.

Who didn’t know?

Certainly those Americans who dwell in the Great Big Center have known this for some time. They bump into each other all day long in the great big country we call “outside the beltway.”

This is not to say centrists always agree with each other. But overall, disagreement is by degrees of difference rather than ideological chasms. They are Democrat, Republican and independent. But what they share is greater than the sum of the extreme parts. Mostly they share a disdain of ideological purity.

What they lack is organization and perhaps self-awareness. There really are enough of them to change the political climate – if only there were someone to harness and channel what I would call their normalcy.

By “normal,” I mean that centrists like to keep as much of their hard-earned cash as possible, but want to help the helpless. They tend to prefer a laissez-faire attitude toward their neighbors. Want to get married? Please. Need an abortion? Fine, but three months is plenty of time to figure it out. People who want to smoke pot in the privacy of their own home do not belong in jail.

Would this be such a strange world?

To the harder-core constituents both left and right, such people have no convictions, hence the derogative “squishy middle.” But lacking the desire to participate in million-something marches or stack barricades in front of the White House or wave some symbol of self-anointed righteousness does not necessarily make one squishy or uninterested. It might make one too sane for politics. It might make one too mature for rabble.

Two words: critical mass. There is power in numbers.

So who are these centrists? This is the real news from the Esquire/NBC poll, which was conducted by pollsters from the Barack Obama and Mitt Romney campaigns. The surveyors identified four pods of individuals who share a patriotic view of the United States, believe in meritocracy (against affirmative action) and are largely libertarian: Pickup Populists (as in “Duck Dynasty” fans), the MBA Middle (highly educated), Minivan Moderates (busy with kids) and WhateverMan (the cynical young who can’t stand any of us).

These are folks, in other words, one might not invite to the same dinner party. Yet they are constituents of a grand, gray base – neither red nor blue nor even purple but vaguely reminiscent of a time when everyone was more or less on the same page.

Fully 58 percent of them are pessimistic about politics in this country, but they trust Democrats more than Republicans. Of all the GOP leaders, only New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie received more than 1 percent (2 percent) in the trust sweeps. Oprah Winfrey got 6 percent. Jon Stewart and Colin Powell each got 1 percent, as did Billy Graham. Rush Limbaugh got zero percent. President Obama won with 9 percent.

The takeaway from this poll – and others showing that more Americans self-identify as independent than Democrat or Republican – is that the country is not as divided as one would imagine. The challenge for the moderate middle is to create an organizing principle – all things in moderation? – and produce a centrist, nonideological, pragmatic leader, preferably one un-indebted to billionaires or radio babbleheads.

A dream, perhaps, but wouldn’t it be marvey?

Editor's Choice Videos

Join the discussion

is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service