Last year, Bruno Bornsztein and Alicia Lacy did something controversial: They painted the dark-stained woodwork in their century-old Dutch Colonial a crisp white.
The residents of St. Paul, Minn., publish the DIY and home decor websites Curbly.com and ManmadeDIY.com, and many of their readers weren’t thrilled when Bornsztein revealed their woodwork plans online.
“Our readers are purists when it comes to woodwork and think it’s a sin to paint it,” Bornsztein said. “But it’s our house, and we'll be living here for 30 years.”
The couple’s home makeover has been a labor of love. When they bought the 1907 house, it had been vacant and neglected, with visible water damage. But it had a good floor plan, a beautiful coffered ceiling and a fireplace with a Mission-style Craftsman mantel. Four bedrooms upstairs offered plenty of room for the family, which, at the time, included a toddler and a baby on the way.
Never miss a local story.
“We love old, unloved houses and want to fix them up,” Lacy said. “We’re the crazy-cat people of old houses. We went into it so blind, but we were optimistic and driven by the potential it had.”
With Bornsztein as general contractor, they demolished and gutted the main floor and part of the upstairs, put in a new furnace, and rewired and replumbed the whole house. It was backbreaking, painstaking work, he said. “We had to take down each one of the trim pieces of the coffered ceiling, number them, and put it all back together.”
Then they made the decision to paint the woodwork, to make the space “brighter, younger and modern,” Lacy said.
With the main living spaces updated, the couple focused on the “dinky kitchen tucked into a back corner.” The cupboards and walls were lemon yellow, and counter space was minimal.
To expand the kitchen and create a mudroom, they built a 600-square-foot, two-story addition on the back of the house. Upstairs, the extra space gave them a master suite with a walk-in closet and bathroom.
Being a DIY guy, Bornsztein pitched in on every project, hiring some out and enlisting friends to help with others. “I’m handy to a point, but I’m not comfortable with building a whole new structure,” he said.
The couple were ready to finish their makeover and integrate the old spaces with the new when they had a fortuitous encounter with Emily Henderson, a Los Angeles designer who won a season of HGTV’s “Design Star” and pens a sassy style blog. After a couple of glasses of wine at a cocktail party in Utah, “Bruno and I floated around the idea of Emily designing some of the rooms in our remodeled home,” Lacy said.
After they recruited a sponsor for the redesign of the “Curbly” family home, which they would document on their website, they called Henderson. She was on board.
“I’m always looking for projects that offer good portfolio work,” Henderson said. “Bruno and Alicia have a big following, good taste and style – and I knew I would have fun that week.”
Yes, one week. Henderson’s assignment was almost like an HGTV reality show: Furnish and decorate four rooms – living and dining, sunroom and master bedroom – in just a few days. Henderson compared the process to a “fast art installation.”
“Their home is traditional, so I wanted it to feel classic, but at the same time, bring in some eclectic midcentury pieces,” she said.
Weeks before Henderson came to town, the couple organized their ideas on Pinterest and sought Henderson’s advice, via e-mail and Skype, on purchasing the main furniture pieces. When she arrived, the trio went on mega-shopping trips everywhere from West Elm and Ikea to thrift and vintage shops. They also mined online sites and designer wholesale sources to fill in with accessories, lighting, artwork and fabrics.
They scored many unique vintage pieces through Craigslist, including a campaign-style dresser for $100, which Bornsztein sanded and sprayed white. In the dining room, a Danish midcentury modern table, wooden slat chairs and credenza are also from Craigslist. A new modern bronze chandelier, with bars that can be reconfigured in any shape, is suspended above the table. The conversation piece of the room is a gallery-like wall displaying different-sized family photos, inside Ikea frames, arranged on an “organic grid” by Henderson.
Henderson’s unfussy design scheme for the living room feels young and modern, yet it’s comfortable for a family with little kids. It’s anchored by a Room & Board tufted-back sofa with midcentury modern curves and a contemporary blue steel-colored area rug from Loloi. Bornsztein re-covered and restored two Danish modern chairs – one of which was passed down from his father.
The sunroom is long and narrow, so Henderson divided it into two spaces. On one end is a bright and cheery breakfast nook, with a Saarinen-style Ikea table, surrounded by vintage Bertoia chairs found on Craigslist, which Bornsztein sandblasted and painted. On the other end is a TV and play room furnished with kid-sized camp stools and a low table matching one in the living room. West Elm pillows and teal lamps add pops of color.
“Emily made the sunroom useful and pretty – not a dumping ground for toys,” Bornsztein said.
On the second floor, the vaulted master bedroom is a melange of vintage modern, old Hollywood glam and airy styling. A navy velvet king-size headboard from Target adds a touch of luxury. “I couldn’t picture it at first; I thought it was over-the-top,” Bornsztein said. “But it really works.” The bed is flanked by campaign-style nightstands, found on Craigslist for $40 and painted gray, which is repeated in the Loloi area rug.
Although the couple worked 10-hour days and had to finance and furnish four rooms all at once, they feel lucky that they connected with Henderson and had the chance to work with her.
“We saw this home on a cold winter day and had an idea to make it into a dream place for our family,” Bornsztein said. “It’s really awesome that we were able to get it done.”