Do we make poorer decisions as we age?

10/14/2013 12:00 AM

08/08/2014 10:19 AM

When it comes to making boneheaded choices, teenagers usually win society’s award for overall poor decision-making.

Yet a study published recently in the journal PNAS suggests that our ability to make wise choices changes over time, and actually declines with old age.

In fact, the study found that in certain situations, the decision-making ability of people older than 65 was worse than that of adolescents. While teens were more apt to drive carelessly, study authors argued that seniors were more likely to make poor medical or financial decisions.

The study involved 135 men and women between ages 12 to 90. Each was assigned a sum of money – $125 – and then asked a series of “lottery questions.” The questions were designed to gauge risk aversion, consistency of thought and rationality.

Seniors “disturbingly” chose irrational wager options 25 percent of the time, according to the study authors. An example of an irrational choice would be to bypass a sure gain of $5 in favor of an ambiguous or risky choice to win the same amount of cash.

By contrast, adolescents chose irrational options 10 percent of the time, while young and midlife adults chose them only 5 percent of the time.

Seniors were far more cautious than the other age groups when choosing between two possible cash gains. If faced with the option of receiving $5 for certain, or a lottery that paid $20 with a 50 percent chance of winning, seniors chose the $5.

When seniors faced a choice between two losses, however, such as losing $5 for certain or choosing a lottery in which they stood a 50 percent chance of losing $20 or nothing, they chose the riskier option with the higher potential loss.

Seniors also lacked consistency, the authors found. When a certain question was asked four times, seniors switched their answers “significantly” more than all other age groups and roughly twice as often as adults ages 21 to 50, the authors found.

The authors argued that the pattern of decision-making among elder participants in the study was not a function of illness or age-related dementia. The 36 seniors who participated in the study were all screened and determined to be healthy.

Senior study author Ifat Levy, an assistant professor of comparative medicine and neurobiology at Yale University in Connecticut, said the findings fall in line with a growing body of research that suggests older adults make decisions detrimental to the wealth, health and general well-being. For instance, they generally borrow at higher interest rates, incorrectly estimate property values and pay more fees to financial institutions.

The reason for such behavior remained a mystery, but it did raise potential policy issues, considering that seniors are more likely to fail to choose health plans correctly and more likely to make voting errors, the authors wrote.

“The decrease in consistency and rationality may be due to a general reduction in cognitive function, which occurs even in healthy aging, although we were surprised that it is so extreme,” Levy said.

Join the Discussion

The Wichita Eagle is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Terms of Service