The road ahead looks good for Romney despite South Carolina

01/22/2012 2:37 PM

08/12/2014 9:30 AM

CHARLESTON, S.C. — The Republican presidential nomination race is momentarily in turmoil. But Mitt Romney, who long ago prepared for a long, methodical slog, is still in strong shape.

"Romney is prepared to grind it out, and no one else is," said Larry Sabato, director of the University of Virginia Center for Politics. "He has a juggernaut, an organization that's first-rate against amateurish organizations in the other campaigns."

Candidates headed Sunday for Florida, site of the next primary Jan. 31. They left with a clear message that South Carolina conservatives were uneasy about Romney and want a fighter like Newt Gingrich who articulates their rage toward the political system. They liked Gingrich's combativeness as he promises to "knock out" President Barack Obama and denounces "elites" in Washington, New York and the media.

But Gingrich, the former Speaker of the House of Representatives who crushed Romney in South Carolina's primary Saturday, is scrambling to assemble a national organization. His campaign has relied almost exclusively on strong TV debate performances. And opponents keep bringing up his controversial political and personal past, which helped sink him in Iowa.

Meanwhile, Texas Rep. Ron Paul and former Pennsylvania Sen. Rick Santorum retain sizeable followings, and though they've been unable to broaden their support, they still fracture the field. That's common in early nomination contests, and the ultimate winner is usually a candidate like Romney who relies on preparation, organization, and money — not momentum.

Every non-incumbent Republican presidential nominee since 1980 has lost at least one primary on the road to nomination, as did non-elected incumbent Jerry Ford in 1976. Romney lost South Carolina, but he's placed first or second in the three states that have voted so far. And he's cultivated a strong firewall of support and organization in Florida for the next challenge.

The Romney camp understood long ago that once the small-state contests are over, the race becomes a quest for delegates to August's Republican National Convention. 1,144 delegates are needed to nominate, and they won't be gathered quickly. Republicans are operating under complex rules this year that award delegates in a variety of ways, making it difficult for anyone to clinch the nomination fast.

By the end of February, only about 15 percent of delegates will have been chosen. Romney's real edge, Sabato said, would become apparent March 6, when Super Tuesday will feature 12 primaries or caucuses. One-fourth of all delegates will be selected that day.

"Only someone like Romney can compete everywhere at once," Sabato said. Gingrich was unable to get on the Virginia's March 6 ballot and reportedly has had trouble filling delegate slates.

Romney has organizations in place in state after state, and "he should be the candidate to be the nominee," said Lance deHaven-Smith, professor of public administration and policy at Florida State University

To be sure, Romney still faces large hurdles — the conservative base of his party hasn't rallied to him — but his path ahead should get smoother. He's got a decent chance to win Florida, and has strong support in upcoming contests in Nevada Feb. 4, Colorado Feb. 7 and Arizona and Michigan Feb. 28.

Romney, though, still must show he can win somewhere other than New Hampshire, where he owns a home and governed the neighboring state.

Florida is a real possibility. "He's been more evident on television, and Florida Republicans are not as conservative as South Carolina Republicans," said Peter Brown, Orlando-based assistant director of the Quinnipiac University Polling Institute.

Typically, insurgents like Gingrich stumble in big states because the strategy that vaulted them to small-state victory doesn't translate to bigger, more-complex states. Visits to five diners a day with 100 people each, which worked in South Carolina, doesn't have the same impact in Florida, which has more than 19 million people and a half-dozen expensive media markets.

Still, Gingrich will not go away easily. He, Paul and Santorum are tapping into voter frustration with the economy and Washington that's been simmering for years. Romney may have the temperament to bring warring factions together, but voters in South Carolina often saw his style as too sterile.

"Romney is not strong in the areas where Obama is weak," said Kendra Stewart, associate professor of political science at the College of Charleston. "Obama's weaknesses are things like crony capitalism and campaign finances, and Romney has some of those same problems."

Romney also has been hurt by his stiff demeanor.

"He did a great job saving the (2002 Winter) Olympics, but I just can't connect with him," said Bobby Jordan, a Florence, S.C., business owner.

Romney's refusal to release his income tax returns helped fuel that feeling. Not only did it suggest arrogance, but "it makes voters wonder what is it that could come out and make Romney vulnerable against Obama," Stewart said.

Romney plans to release 2010 returns and 2011 tax estimates on Tuesday; he said Sunday that his reluctance to do so earlier was a mistake. Indeed, controversy over the issue bogged him down all last week.

Gingrich's confrontational style is very different. He dominated both South Carolina TV debates last week, which were pivotal in persuading voters that he was best able to beat Obama.

"He has a way of seizing the moment like nobody I've ever seen," said David Woodard, professor of political science at Clemson University.

But traditionally, it's hard to convert a candidate's empathy with voter anger into a national campaign against a rival who's assembled a well-financed and nationwide political organization as Romney has.

"Mechanics matter," said Tallahassee-based GOP consultant David Johnson.

Recent history offers three scenarios for such battles:

  • The well-organized candidate wins but is badly hurt. Colorado Sen. Gary Hart stunned former Vice President Walter Mondale in the 1984 New Hampshire Democratic primary. Mondale, a veteran insider, couldn't ignite the same passion as Hart, but won the nomination with strong support from labor unions, minorities and elected officials. But he never clicked with most voters; in November he won only his home state of Minnesota against Ronald Reagan.
  • The well-organized candidate adapts and becomes gets stronger. Often, losses like Romney's jolt the candidate and make them revamp their strategy. After Arizona Sen. John McCain trounced George W. Bush in the 2000 New Hampshire primary, Bush got tougher — some would say downright nasty — and quickly buried McCain.
  • The fight continues through spring and a divided party takes months to heal. Sometimes the healing comes too late — Democrats lost the White House in 1968 and 1980 after bruising nomination fights, and Republicans had a hard time unifying in 1976, and lost.
  • But four years ago, Obama and New York Sen. Hillary Clinton, both with strong organizations, brawled until the primary season ended in June. By the fall, though, the party was united and Obama won an easy victory.

    The path to Romney's nomination is unclear, but the outcome, Sabato said, is probably not.

    "He's very well-positioned," Sabato said.

    MORE FROM McCLATCHY

    Suddenly Romney's on the ropes as developments rock GOP race

    Gingrich rode big debate skills-and homebody Southern style-tp S.C. victory

    /www.mcclatchydc.com/2012/0{1/136532/gingrich-appears-to-be-headed.html">Gingrich wins huge come-from-behind victory in South Carolina

    Check out McClatchy's politics blog: Planet Washington

Join the Discussion

The Wichita Eagle is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Terms of Service