Laughable plot sinks ‘Battleship’
05/17/2012 5:00 AM
05/17/2012 11:23 AM
There will be bigger movies this summer, and better ones and worse ones.
But there will not be a dumber movie than “Battleship.”
Ponderous and pandering, shameless and head-slappingly silly, this Navy vs. Aliens epic delivers a few thrills and a few laughs. In between the head-slaps, that is.
A pointless prologue establishes that NASA has sent signals to a distant Earth-like planet. Warnings from one scientist (Hamish Linklater, of “The New Adventures of Old Christine,” has the Jeff Goldblum role) that this is like the Incans inviting Conquistadors to visit are ignored.
Meanwhile, a reckless repeat offender named Alex Hopper (Taylor Kitsch) gets a bit buzzed on his birthday and commits a grand gesture (and very funny) break-in, just to fetch a microwave burrito for hottie Sam (model-turned-actress Brooklyn Decker). It’s jail or the Navy, declares his Navy officer brother (Alexander Skarsgard).
That sets the table for the Hopper brothers’ Navy service, and for the day the aliens come — in big, cumbersome, gear-and-shape-shifting ships which they use to encase a corner of Hawaii and the Pacific in a shielded bubble that means only three guided-missile destroyers — two American, one Japanese — can halt the coming invasion.
The folks we follow here are the brothers, on different ships; a couple of enlisted sailors, including the obligatory pop-star-as-actress (Rihanna); and Sam in tight jogging shorts as she motivates legless vet Gregory D. Gadson through rehab and back into action because America needs him.
“Let’s see if we can buy the world another day,” he mutters.
And the folks we don’t follow include Liam Neeson, admiral of the fleet and leader of a mass joint exercise that is going on at the time of the attack, a fleet that can’t pitch and is thus irrelevant to the plot and forgotten for much of the picture.
The basic set-up owes a lot to “Independence Day,” the effects play like “Transformers,” and the banter occasionally rises to the level of amusing.
Erich and Jon Hoeber, who wrote the script, set up rules for this universe, and then break them. They commit great gaffes of logic in the name of convenience. Actor-turned-director Peter Berg (“The Rundown,” the original “Friday Night Lights” movie) had a tough job, ignoring the holes in the plot, staging one clever cat-and-mouse-with-missiles scene to play like the Hasbro board game this is based on, shooting the whole thing like a slick, gray steel-and-sea-spray Navy recruiting film.
And kudos to whoever had the idea of filling this picture with veterans — in the rehab center where Sam works, in other key moments in the movie. Yes, it’s pandering, but it could pay off with the paying customers.
But few will walk out of the theater with much more than the knowledge that they’ve seen one of the goofiest special effects epics in years, a picture that doesn’t stand up to even a 10-year-old’s scrutiny.
After this and “John Carter,” Taylor Kitsch should start using his middle initial. A 13-letter name might help explain away his bad luck in blockbusters.
Join the Discussion
The Wichita Eagle is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.