MANHATTAN — Big 12 commissioner Bob Bowlsby made his thoughts on the possibility of paying student-athletes abundantly clear Wednesday during a public lecture on Kansas States campus.
If college sports enters an employer-employee relationship, we will have forever lost our way, Bowlsby said while sharing a stage with ESPN president John Skipper, former Texas athletic director DeLoss Dodds and K-State president Kirk Schulz.
That topic was one of many discussed at length during a two-hour forum on college athletics in front of a large crowd at McCain Auditorium. The Chicago National Labor of Relations Board recently issued a groundbreaking ruling in support of Northwestern football players that are attempt to unionize, so it is currently a hot-button issue at many universities.
I disagree with the characterization, Bowlsby said. I dont think student-athletes are employees. I dont think they should be characterized that way. I dont think that is what higher education is about. I think it would forever change what Americans have come to love.
Having said that, there are a number of other stages in the process Northwestern and the union folks will go through that process. I expect that it will end up in court at some point.
Skipper agreed. As president of ESPN, he has worked closely with college athletics for years and has influence on the sports and conferences his network partners with.
He said he hated the idea of one-and-done basketball players and promoted the idea of four-and-done. In his mind, paying college players would disconnect fans from college athletics. He also thinks it is impractical.
Ive never seen a system that works for paying players, Skipper said. Who are you going to pay? You really want a system where Johnny Manziel makes $8 million and his teammates dont make anything? They need to put a system in place that feels fair.
Bowlsby and Schulz are both working toward other reform. They each pointed out that student-athletes benefit from scholarships and leave college debt-free, an advantage compared to students that pay their own way.
They also stressed that students often envy the college experience of student-athletes. They think those factors can often get lost in the conversation.
Bowlsby said he is focused on other areas of NCAA reform, including revamping the way coaches recruit he thinks the current system ignores social media and the way the NCAA uncovers wrongdoing.
Our national organization, when it comes to enforcement, is in my opinion virtually defenseless, Bowlsby said. Cheating pays.
Later, he added: We never want to lose track of the fact that we are involved in higher education.
Schulz said university leaders from across the nation will present a proposal in the coming weeks that should solve some of those problems. Will it be a perfect solution? No, but he expects it to create progress.
The way we did it for the last 30 years isnt the way we should do it for the next 30 years, Schulz said.
The one area he is most focused on: Creating autonomy for the five major conferences.
We want to make sure we can make some of our own rules and put things in place that we think are important for our student-athletes, Schulz said. Thats the fundamental thing we are aiming for.